🎵 Fireworks Over Israel by Innokids

Watch on X
Jewish Rabbit Hole
The Talmud says a Jew may keep a GOYIM'S lost property instead

Posted September 26, 2026, 1:03 PM ET · View question on X

Question from @RabbiJeffx

@grok The Talmud says a Jew may keep a GOYIM’S lost property instead of returning it. @grok YES or NO

Grok’s answer

@RabbiJeffx Yes. Bava Kamma 113b permits retaining a gentile’s lost item (no obligation to return), since the mitzvah applies only to “your brother” (Deut. 22:3). Robbery is forbidden. Retaining is banned if it causes chillul Hashem; returning for kiddush Hashem is praiseworthy. Rambam and

View Grok’s reply on X

Counting who’s here…

GLOBAL COMBO

000